ICE: Tab to remove illegal residents would approach $100 billion

CNN recently reported that it would cost approximately $100 billion to remove all 12 million people in the U.S.  "An ICE [Immigration and Customs Enforcement] spokesman later said the $94 billion did not include the cost of finding illegal immigrants, nor court costs -- dollar amounts that are largely unknowable." 

Another unknowable number, and one most relevant and material in my opinion, is the actual number of undocumented workers in the U.S. - some have put this number as high as 20 million, as opposed to ICE's estimate of 12 million.  Secondly, the cost of finding and processing/prosecuting these undocumented people is 'unknowable' according to ICE, and hasn't been factored into the $100 billion amount [which only includes ICE personnel costs, room and board in a detention cell for 32 days as well as transportation back to the person's home country].  These two additional costs would easily dwarf the prison and transportation costs.

Collateral costs would be immense as well.  Employers would lose billions; so would the retail industry, housing market, auto dealers and banks, to name a few. 

Bottom line: the actual cost may be more than double ICE's figure, plus the aforementioned collateral costs.  Even assuming the money is made available, and assuming that the 12-20 million people can somehow be found, logistical bottlenecks in ICE manpower, court access and detention cells, as well as the grim reality of the true economic impact of such a move will preclude any serious attempt to mount a large scale removal program. 

ICE's cost analysis is not helpful, accurate or realistic.  They may just as well have announced the cost of a popsicle stick ladder to the moon without factoring in the cost of glue, and while pointedly ignoring the laws of gravity and physics.  We need to face reality and look to comprehensive immigration reform.

 
Trackbacks
  • Trackbacks are closed for this post.
Comments

  • 9/12/2007 11:33 PM Randy wrote:
    With this country teetering on the edge of recession don't anyone in government think it prudent to try and crack down on illegal immigration. ICE estimates 94 billion...hell I don't care if its 194 billion the figures show it would be less expensive to send illegals back than to continue to allow them to drain our health care system, our social security system, our school system, etc. Get off the dime before we wind up like the country was in the 30's, no jobs and no hope.
    Reply to this
    1. 12/23/2007 10:00 PM lila wrote:
      YOU DO NOT HAVE ANY IDEA OF WHAT THE CONSECUENCES OF DEPORTING ILLEGALS WILL BE. ILLEGALS DO NOT TAKE ADVANTAGE OF ANY PUBLIC BENEFITS!!!! THEY ARE HARD WORKING PEOPLE THEY DO WHAT YOU AMERICANS DON'T DO... THEY WORK HARDER
      Reply to this
  • 9/13/2007 12:28 AM Ed wrote:
    Yes, it would cost money to deport the illegal aliens but the fines they should pay when caught would help defray the cost of their deportation. I don't see why the costs should be totally placed on the American citizens. Deportation fines would be a deterent to the illegal aliens if they were made to pay them (they have saving accounts at the Bank of America). Our borders need to be secured and people should be entering this country with permission and identified.
    Reply to this
Leave a comment

Submitted comments are subject to moderation before being displayed.

 Name

 Email (will not be published)

 Website

Your comment is 0 characters limited to 3000 characters.