US immigration hearings to begin

Via BBC News

Republicans are set to open a series of public hearings around the US on the controversial issue of immigration.

Republicans in the House of Representatives are seeking approval for the House’s tough immigration bill in a hearing in San Diego.

But Republican senators have set up their own session in Philadelphia to back a more liberal Senate proposal.

The issue has divided the party, with President George Bush’s vision initially closer to that of the Senate.

However, reports suggest the president is now moving closer to the conservative line.

The decision by Republican House leaders to call public hearings on the issue was seen by many as a serious setback for the president, who has been trying to see a bill passed ahead of mid-term elections in November.

The House and Senate have passed their own contrasting immigration bills, but work to reconcile the two bills is now delayed until the hearings are over.

Both bills seek to tighten border security, but while the Senate bill includes a guest-worker programme and offers illegal immigrants a “path to citizenship”, the House’s “enforcement-only” bill seeks to deport illegal immigrants and make it a felony to remain in the US illegally.

Democrats have dismissed the hearings as political theatre.


Wednesday’s first hearing will take place at a San Diego Border Patrol station.

Reports suggest Republicans will use the hearing to highlight the dangers of terrorists getting across the border and to assess improvements in border security since 11 September 2001.


HOUSE BILL (passed December)

Focuses on border security

Backs construction of fence along border with Mexico

Makes it a felony to live in the US illegally instead of a civil offence

Seeks to deport illegal immigrants

SENATE BILL (passed May)

Also toughens border security

Allows some illegal immigrants to seek US citizenship

Proposes guest-worker programme

“My mission is to investigate our border security shortcomings post-9/11,” said Ed Royce, a California Republican and chairman of the House’s International Relations subcommittee on International Terrorism and Non-proliferation which is behind the hearings.

“The problem is that border security has become national security.”

Another hearing will take place in Laredo, Texas on Friday, and reports suggest Arizona will also host one of the hearings.

Meanwhile, senators have organised their own hearing in Philadelphia on Wednesday to defend the broad scope of the Senate immigration bill.

The hearing will “develop a broader, factual, evidentiary record on the need for the comprehensive bill, which is challenged by quite a number of House members”, said the host of the meeting, Sen Arlen Specter – himself a Pennsylvania Republican.

Bush address border patrol agents
Bush is said to be shifting his stance on immigration

But the New York Times newspaper reports that President Bush, whose stance on immigration initially appeared to correspond more closely with the Senate bill, is moving closer to a compromise with conservatives on immigration.

It quotes Candi Wolff, White House director of legislative affairs, as saying Mr Bush is considering “triggers” on the immigration bill.

This refers to the idea that the guest-worker and “path to citizenship” schemes which Mr Bush has publicly backed could be introduced only once border-security targets have been met.

This “enforcement-first” approach would bring Mr Bush much closer to the “enforcement-only” measures demanded by his Republican colleagues in the House.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: